
The Sleepy Hollow Incident: Book One: A Gothic Tale!
NOTE TO READERS: The Sleepy Hollow Incident was originally published as a four-book rapid release serial in October of 2025. In order to manage expectations, I would like for you to know that The Sleepy Hollow Incident is not a series, meaning, although the story is divided into four books, each book is a continuation from the last with one streamlined narrative across the entire story. In order to fully grasp the complexity and, without a doubt, the conclusion of the story you will need to read all four books, which are also presented in the book titled, The Sleepy Hollow Incident: The Complete Gothic Tale! I request for all readers to keep this in mind when posting your review. Should you have any questions, feel free to reach out to me.With gratitude,PD Alleva
Get This Book
As an Amazon Associate, Inside Story earns from qualifying purchases
Available in: Hardcover, Paperback, and on Kindle Unlimited
See all editions (5)Reader Reviews
4 ratings
Crystal O.
This was a fantastic spin on Sleepy Hallow story. I love his writing style and honestly it crushed me a little but cant wait to dive into the next part of this story! A little goth,romance, and a lot of horror! Excellent book!
Liz M.
This one had all the ingredients for a dark, addictive read—small-town secrets, a soul-for-love bargain, eerie murders—but it didn’t fully land for me.
The premise? Genuinely chilling. A romance writer trading his soul to save the woman he loves, only for it to spiral into something ancient and sinister? I was in. The atmosphere in Sleepy Hollow’s woods and the creeping sense of dread were easily the strongest parts—there’s a moody, gothic vibe that almost carries the whole story.
But the execution felt uneven. The pacing jumps between slow, heavy exposition and rushed plot reveals, which made it hard to stay fully hooked. Some of the horror elements (especially the satanic/medieval torture angle) leaned more into shock than depth, and I found myself wanting more emotional weight—especially between Marc and Lori, since their relationship is supposed to anchor everything.
The concept of love vs. damnation is powerful, but it never quite hits as hard as it should. By the time things escalated to the bigger supernatural stakes, I wasn’t as invested as I wanted to be.
Still, if you’re into dark bargains, eerie settings, and morally twisted love stories, this might scratch that itch—it just didn’t fully deliver on its potential for me.
⭐⭐⭐
Tracy W.
Koen S.