The Highland Fling (True Scotsman, #2)
Amy McGavin
Reader Reviews
3.0
1 rating
Liz M.
Apr 26, 2026
The Highland Fling brings us a romance that starts with a spark and takes an unexpected turn into parenthood. The setup is promising: a fiercely independent heroine, a swoon-worthy Scottish playboy, and the kind of “oops” moment that could change everything. There’s banter, undeniable chemistry, and of course—a classic “only one bed” scene for the trope-lovers.
But while the premise is juicy, the execution felt a bit uneven. The heroine’s transformation from “done with men” to navigating surprise motherhood was compelling but at times rushed. Aidan, with his sky-blue eyes and flirty charm, seems like he should be more than just a reformed rake—but we never get quite deep enough into his motivations to fully buy into his sudden change of heart.
The pacing dragged in spots, especially once the pregnancy storyline kicked in, and the emotional stakes—though present—didn’t always land with the punch I wanted. That said, the Scottish Highlands setting was lovely, and fans of small-town-meets-big-city romances will still find cozy, heartwarming moments to enjoy.
Overall, this one’s a mixed bag: sweet, sexy, and full of potential, but it didn’t fully sweep me off my feet.
But while the premise is juicy, the execution felt a bit uneven. The heroine’s transformation from “done with men” to navigating surprise motherhood was compelling but at times rushed. Aidan, with his sky-blue eyes and flirty charm, seems like he should be more than just a reformed rake—but we never get quite deep enough into his motivations to fully buy into his sudden change of heart.
The pacing dragged in spots, especially once the pregnancy storyline kicked in, and the emotional stakes—though present—didn’t always land with the punch I wanted. That said, the Scottish Highlands setting was lovely, and fans of small-town-meets-big-city romances will still find cozy, heartwarming moments to enjoy.
Overall, this one’s a mixed bag: sweet, sexy, and full of potential, but it didn’t fully sweep me off my feet.